Saturday, August 13, 2011

Wealth Concentration - Yes. Central Planning? Not so much.

My facebook feed was filled today with links to a post by Tim O'Reilly which itself references this post by John Robb. John theorizes that centralized planning is to be blamed for the recent hurdles the US Economy is facing.

The summary of John's hypothesis is as following:

  1. The USSR failed because of central economic decision making.
  2. Decision making in such a complex system can only be made efficiently by letting the players in the market make small parallel decisions - that is, letting the "market" work.
  3. The US was successful because it was very good at letting markets work. However:
  4. Recently, too much centralized government planning leads to misallocation of resources.
  5. But more importantly, the increasing concentration of U.S. wealth among a handful of rich people leads to even more centralized decision making - only those wealthy enough make the decisions, and they control most of the assets to decide on.
I liked the theory, as it is novel, and gives a new angle to the causes of the recent economic crisis.

I am quite positive, however, that wealth concentration is neither evidence, nor a cause for central planning and its failure in the U.S.

The reason is that wealth concentration hasn't changed tremendously in the last 90 years in the U.S.

And here's why.

As support for his claim about wealth concentration in the U.S., John shows the US Income distribution graph from the NYTimes Economix blog:


If you don't like reading graphs, the one line summary is: "The top rich 0.1% make much much more than all the rest". This indeed shows that income is very unequal in the U.S.

To verify John's hypothesis, we can do three things:
  1. Focus on wealth, and not on income. If the claim is about wealth concentration, why look at income and not total assets owned by people?
  2. See if it changed over time - suppose the U.S. was always unequal about its wealth distribution - in that case, the recent economic issues are probably not a result of that inequality.
  3. Compare it to other countries - If there are other countries, with unequal wealth distribution, and even central planning, do they also face similar problems?
To answer these questions, we need data. Luckily, this page by Sociologist Bill Domhoff from UCSC has all the information required to answer these questions.

So let's start:
  • Is wealth concentrated by a handful of people in the U.S.?
The probable answer is Yes, as can be seen from this NYTimes Economix Graph:


This graph shows that the top 1% of U.S. population controls between 20%-30% of the wealth in the USA.

  • Did wealth concentration change drastically in the last 80+ years?

The probable answer is No.

The following graph, with data as old as 1922, shows that the wealth concentration in the U.S did not change dramatically over the last 25 years or so. To add on that, there is less wealth concentrated in the U.S. by the top 1% today than there was during the 1990s, and roughly the same amount as in the 1960s and 1930s. One caveat is that the data goes only up to 2007, but probably hasn't changed much:

Source: Adapted from Wealth, Income, and Power

This means the U.S. was always unequal in its wealth distribution. 

It's not a recent phenomenon.

  • So how does the U.S. compare to other countries?

The data I found was for the year 2000 (I didn't look too much, though), but let's assume no dramatic changes have happened in wealth concentration since 2000. Also, changes did happen, they probably went in the same direction for most countries. The data is for the top 10% of the population, not the top 1%:



wealth owned
by top 10%
Switzerland71.3%
United States69.8%
Denmark65.0%
France61.0%
Sweden58.6%
UK56.0%
Canada53.0%
Norway50.5%
Germany44.4%
Finland42.3%

The table clearly shows that although the U.S. has most of its wealth concentrated in the top 10% of the population, this is also the case for Switzerland, Sweden, France, and Denmark. 
All of these countries have very centralized planning. 
Many of them have very high tax rates compared to the U.S.

Some of them are in bad shape.

But Switzerland seems to be doing well, no matter what. Especially given its wealth concentration.

Conclusion: We can't really conclude anything from this short exposition of data, but it looks probable that wealth concentration did not cause more centralized planning which did not cause the recent difficulty the U.S. economy is facing.

36 comments:

Andy Strauss said...

Great work dude, Thanks for spending the time to describe this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic.

Marketing Research

jennifer white said...

If we take a look at the graphs and results by global wealth management, wealthy nations with huge corporate blue chips have done wealth increase through diversification while the traditional consolidated portfolio are struggling.

Andrew Collins said...

Impressive blog! I'm actually researching on how to manage my finances and I'm glad to learn from you, I'm taking online certified financial planner course, studying very well so that I can avoid being in debt.

honey thomas said...

I have learned that thriving in a tough economic setting for individuals in their careers and respective finances is relative to their capacity and it should neither be credited with the government and their economic performance basis. I sustain my passive income with internet businesses that make money.

Scarlett Carroll said...

An organization should inform themselves on what particular program will best fit to their businesses. In this way, they can make sure that they are choosing the right program for what they need. -Scarlett C.

Chezka Aguila said...

Very well said thanks for sharing this post I'm a student taking up financial course and having acertified financial advisor certificationis really a big thing to me. cheers!

Dedi Abdullah said...

obat kanker serviks di apotik
obat kanker serviks yang sudah parah
obat kanker serviks akut
obat kanker rahim yang sudah parah
kanker serviks herbal
kanker rahim herbal
obat kanker serviks herbal
pengobatan kanker serviks herbal
herbal kanker serviks
pengobatan kanker serviks dengan herbal
pengobatan kanker serviks secara herbal
pencegahan kanker serviks secara herbal

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Palmerah Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kemanggisan Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Slipi Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rawa Buaya Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Mangga Besar Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tubagus Angke Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kali Deres Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Petojo Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Sukabumi Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kampung Baru Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jembatan Lima Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kota Bambu Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tambora Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Puri Kembangan Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bojong Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Duri Kosambi Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Duri Kepa Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Mangga Dua Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Taman Sari Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Basmoll Jakarta Barat

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jelambar Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rawa Belong Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Batu Sari Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bandara Sokarno Hatta Jakarta
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tanjung Duren Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tomang Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kelapa Dua Jakarta Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cipulir Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Simprug Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Blok - M Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Gandaria Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Taman Puring Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Barito Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Fatal Senayan Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pejompongan Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Sudirman Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pancoran Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tebet Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pasar Burung Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pasar Rumput Jakarta Selatan

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pasar Minggu Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pejaten Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Panglima Polim Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kemang Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kampung Kandang Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cinere Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Lebak Bulus Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pasar Jum'at Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pondok Cabe Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Komplek Pondok Indah Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tanah Kusir Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rempoa Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Radio Dalam Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jagakarsa Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Lenteng Agung Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cilandak Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kebagusan Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Manggarai Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jati Padang Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pondok Labu Jakarta Selatan

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Ciganjur Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tanjung Barat Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Mampang Prapatan Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Petukangan Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Fatmawati Jakarta Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tanah Abang Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Senen Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pertokoan Harco Glodok
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kota Tua Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pasar Baru Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Banteng Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bendungan Hilir Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cempaka Mas Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Komplek Duta Melin Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kelapa Gading Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kwitang Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Keramat Raya Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Stasiun Gambir Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Menteng Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Matraman Jakarta Pusat

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cikini Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Sunter Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Johar Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Gondangdia Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pegangsaan Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kampung Bali Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Paseban Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Sawah Besar Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kebon Sirih Jakarta Pusat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tanjung Priok Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cilincing Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Marunda Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pluit Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pulau Pramuka Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Muara Angke Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Muara Baru Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cakung Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Koja Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pademangan Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kapuk Muara Jakarta Utara

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pegadungan Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pejagalan Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rorotan Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rawa Badak Jakarta Utara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pulo Gadung Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Condet Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cawang Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bulak Kapal Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pondok Gede Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rawa Lumbu Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pekayon Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kali Malang Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Duren Sawit Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kranji Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jati Negara Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Keramat Jati Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rengas Dengklok Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kalibata Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Perdatam Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kampung Rambutan Jakarta Timur

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Duren Tiga Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cipinang Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Klender Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Ciracas Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cijantung Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cibubur Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cipayung Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bantar Gebang Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rawamangun Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cililitan Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pinang Ranti Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pasar Rebo Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jati Asih Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jati Warna Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di JakaSampurna Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kuniran Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bambu Apus Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cilangkap Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kampung Melayu Jakarta Timur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Badung Bali

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bangli Bali
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Buleleng Bali
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Gianyar Bali
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jembrana Bali
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Karangasem Bali
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Klungkung Bali
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tabanan Bali
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Denpasar Bali
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bogor
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bekasi
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tangerang
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Cilegon
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pandeglang
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bandung
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jakarta
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Surabaya
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Medan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Malang
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Balikpapan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Semarang

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Palembang
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Makasar
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Batam
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jogja
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Aceh
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bener Meriah
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bireuen
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Gayo Lues
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Nagan Raya
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pidie
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pidie Jaya
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Simeulue
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Banda Aceh
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Langsa
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Lhokseumawe
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Sabang
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Subulussalam
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Asahan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Batubara
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Dairi

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Deli Serdang
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Humbang Hasundutan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Karo
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Labuhanbatu
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Langkat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Mandailing Natal
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Nias
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Padang Lawas
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pakpak Bharat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Samosir
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Serdang Bedagai
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Simalungun
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tapanuli Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Toba Samosir
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Binjai
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Gunungsitoli
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Medan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Padangsidempuan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pematangsiantar
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Sibolga

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tanjungbalai
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tebing Tinggi
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bengkulu
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kaur
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kepahiang
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Lebong
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Mukomuko
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rejang Lebong
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Seluma
Toko Obat Sipilis Di batanghari
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bungo
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kerinci
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Merangin
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Muaro Jambi
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Sarolangun
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tebo
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Jambi
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bengkalis
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kampar
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kuantan Singingi

OBAT DENATURE said...

Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pelalawan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rokan Hilir
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Rokan Hulu
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Siak
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kepulauan Meranti
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Dumai
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pekanbaru
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Agam
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Dharmasraya
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Kepulauan Mentawai
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Lima Puluh Kota
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Padang Pariaman
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pasaman
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pasaman Barat
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Pesisir Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Sijunjung
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Solok
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Solok Selatan
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Tanah Datar
Toko Obat Sipilis Di Bukittinggi

Rebecca said...

packers and movers in Delhi
http://www.logisticmart.com/delhi/packers-and-movers
packers and movers in Mumbai
http://www.logisticmart.com/mumbai/packers-and-movers
packers and movers in Bangalore
http://www.logisticmart.com/bangalore/packers-and-movers
packers and movers in gurgaon
http://www.logisticmart.com/gurgaon/packers-and-movers

Greenwood Jonny said...

WONDERFUL Post.thanks for share..more wait .. …
obat gonore herbal manjur
obat herbal untuk kanker serviks dan kanker payudara
obat kutil kelamin yang sudah terbukti manjur
cara merontokkan kutil dengan mudah dan cepat
obat kutil kelamin khusus untuk pria
bagaimana cara mengobati kutil kelamin
jual obat untuk kutil kelamin
salep dan kapsul untuk kutil kelamin
obat kutil kelamin tanpa operasi
obat wasir herbal yang manjur dan aman
cara cepat mengobati kutil kelamin
mengobati kencing nanah dengan obat herbal
obat keputihan herbal
obat kanker payudara
mempersempit vagina dengan obat herbal
gejala kutil kelamin

obat herbal kutil kelamin said...


obat kencing keluar nanah
obat untuk kencing keluar nanah
obat kampung kencing nanah
obat herbal gonore atau kencing nanah
cara mengobati gonore dengan obat herbal
cara mengobati kencing nanah dengan obat alami
obat kencing nanah herbal manjur


obat gonore herbal said...

very nice post, i certainly love this website, keep on it
kenapa kencing terasa ngilu
kenapa kencing berdarah
Cara obati penyakit sipilis
Bagaimana cara mengobati penyakit sipilis
Mengobati kutil di vagina
Mengenali gejala gonore atau kencing nanah
Cara cepat obati kutil kelamin
Obat kutil kelamin di anus

obat herbal denature said...

very nice article and the contents of the article are of sufficient quality. hopefully more successful and hopefully this article can be useful for the visitors.
callusol apa bisa untuk kutil kelamin?
obt kutil kelamin wilayah lampung
kutil kelamin di liang vagina
Yang jual obat kutil kelamin di daerah bngkinang ada tidak?
jual obat untuk kutil kelamin di kota semarang
jual obat kutil penis daerah sorong

obat herbal denature said...

hopefully this article can be useful for the visitors.
jual obat kutil kelamin di solo
gatal berlebihan dimuara Vagina
obat kutil kelamin manjur
obat kutil kelamin
obat kutil kelamin manjur dan aman
obat kutil kelamin manjur dan aman

tyler durden said...

Thanks....hopefully this article can be useful for the visitors.
obat kencing nanah yang cepat sembuh
obat herbal untuk penyakit sipilis

obat kutil kelamin yang alami said...

Thank You dear....hopefully this article can be useful for the visitors.
obat penyakit raja singa dari bahan alami
obat wasir herbal

obat kutil kelamin yang alami said...

WONDERFUL Post.thanks for share..more wait .. …
obat kutil kelamin
obat kutil kelamin manjur
obat kutil kelamin salep dan kapsul
obat kutil dan herpes dari alam
obat kutil kelamin yang sudah terbukti manjur
obat kutil kelamin yang aman tanpa efek samping
obat kutil kelamin tanpa operasi
obat herbal untuk kutil kelamin
obat manjur untuk kutil kelamin
cara alami mengobati kencing nanah

obat raja singa said...

Thanks for share..more wait
obat kutil kelamin dari bahan alami
obat kutil di kemaluan

obat raja singa said...


semoga bermanfaat... terima kasih....
obat sipilis yang manjur
obat kutil kelamin khusus untuk pria

http://packersmoversbangalore-in.blogspot.in/ said...

I must say you had done a tremendous job,I appreciate all your efforts.Thanks alot for your writings......Waiting for a new 1.. We Provide Best Packers And Movers Bangalore List for Get Free Best Quotes, Compare Charges, Save Money And Time,
Household Shifting Services. @ Packers And Movers in Bangalore

obat kutil kelamin yang alami said...

semoga bermanfaat,,,
mengobati kutil kelamin dengan obat herbal
mengobati iritasi pada kelamin

tyler durden said...

thanks....
cara mengobati sipilis dengan obat alami
cara cepat menghilangkan kutil

obat herbal kutil kelamin said...

thanks....
cara mengobati gonore dengan obat alami
cara cepat menghilangkan kutil

Herbal de nature said...

thanks....
cara mengobati gonore dengan obat alami
cara cepat merontokkan kutil

tyler durden said...

mengobati kutil kelamin dengan obat herbal
mengobati kutil kelamin dengan cepat dan mudah
jual obat untuk kutil di penis
jual obat untuk penis yang ada kutilnya
jual obat untuk bintik bintik di sekitar penis
jual obat untuk bintik bintik di kepala penis
bagaimana cara mengobati kutil di kemaluan
obat kutil kelamin
obat gonore kencing nanah yang manjur